Is Your Black Friday Countdown Timer a Legal Risk?

Canada's Competition Bureau has obtained a court order to advance its investigation into Old Navy and Gap. The Bureau announced the order on November 18, nine days before Black Friday.

According to the Bureau's news release, the investigation concerns potentially false or misleading claims made by the two brands, both operated by Gap Inc. The Bureau says there has been no finding of wrongdoing. Marketing News Canada has asked Gap Inc. for comment.

For marketers, the bigger story is the list of tactics under review. Most of them will look familiar to anyone who has built a holiday sale.

Timers, low-stock alerts and “Price Drop” claims are all under review

The Bureau is looking first at whether regular prices are genuine when products are advertised as being on sale. It is also examining:

  • urgency cues, such as limited-time offers, countdown timers or clocks

  • messages suggesting products are in short supply, such as “Selling Fast" or “Only a Few Left"

  • popularity claims, such as the number of people viewing or buying a product

  • claims about past prices or discounts, such as “Price Drop" or “Best Deal in 30 days"

The order was granted by the Federal Court of Canada. It requires Old Navy and Gap to hand over records and written information relevant to the investigation.

The Bureau has raised this every November since 2024

In November 2024, days before Black Friday, the Bureau published a consumer alert on fake urgency cues. Five days before that, it had obtained a court order in a similar investigation into Leon's and The Brick, looking at sale end dates, potentially inflated regular prices and sale claims with no stated discount. There was no conclusion of wrongdoing in that case either.

A year later, after what it described as a surge in complaints about inflated regular prices, the Bureau warned businesses directly that advertising a made-up regular price is illegal. As an example, it said a business can't advertise “$100, now $50" if the item never actually sold at $100.

The Bureau has settled a case on these grounds before. In 2023, The Dufresne Group agreed to pay a $3.25 million penalty after the Bureau concluded it had advertised big discounts off inflated regular prices. It also found that some deals stayed available after a countdown timer had expired.

Fewer than half of Canadians trust a markdown

The regulator's concerns line up with what shoppers are saying. Boston Consulting Group surveyed 1,000 Canadian consumers for its 2026 Black Friday study, part of a larger survey across ten countries.

Fewer than half of Canadians trust a marked-down price at face value. In the US, that figure is 62%.

BCG found four cues that consistently earn Canadians' trust: money-back guarantees or free returns, a retailer's reputation, clear comparisons between regular and sale prices, and reviews from verified buyers.

Scarcity cues split shoppers by age

Pressure tactics were less convincing overall, but BCG found a split by generation. Gen Z and Millennials treat scarcity messages and influencer recommendations as positive signals of value. Gen X and Boomers read them the opposite way.

BCG measured this with a net trust score: the share who say a cue increases their trust, minus the share who say it decreases it. An influencer recommendation scored +21 among Gen Z and −32 among Boomers.

Younger shoppers are also the ones feeling the most budget pressure. In a Leger survey of 1,452 Canadians for CPA Canada, 47% of holiday shoppers aged 18 to 34 said they expect more spending stress this year, compared with 25% of those 55 and older.

In a single Black Friday campaign aimed at everyone, urgency messaging that nudges a younger shopper may push an older one away. Those are also the tactics the Bureau is now examining.

Flyers still beat TikTok in Canada

BCG also asked shoppers which channels lead them to a purchase decision. In-store advertising was named by 29% and flyers by 21%. Instagram came in at 13% and TikTok at 11%.

Offline channels play a bigger role in Canada than in any other country BCG surveyed, including the US. Social media as a place to discover products dropped 12 percentage points in Canada from last year, a steeper fall than the global average.

Amazon was the most influential shopping channel, named by 39% of Canadians. In BCG's reading, Canadians find products all over but settle on a purchase in the places where they can compare prices for themselves.

What to check in your campaign before November 27

The Bureau has already published guidance on most of the tactics in the Old Navy and Gap investigation. Its page on fake urgency cues and its 2025 warning on regular prices cover the main points.

  • Your “regular" price has to hold up. The Bureau sets out two tests. Either more than half of the product's sales happened at that price or higher within a reasonable period, usually within a year, before or after the promotion. Or the product was offered in good faith at that price or higher for a substantial period, usually within a year, right before or after it. Good faith, in the Bureau's words, means the retailer honestly believes the price is fair and expects customers will actually pay it.

  • Keep records of every promotion: dates, discounts, regular prices and any other savings claims.

  • Countdown timers shouldn't run out or reset while the sale price stays in place.

  • Sales should end when you say they end, and shouldn't run for a long time or repeat every week.

  • Claims about stock left or demand, including how many other shoppers are looking at a product, need to be accurate.

  • Avoid vague savings claims you can't back up, such as “20% off our regular price" when the regular price isn't stated.

The Bureau notes that the consequences for deceptive marketing can include significant monetary penalties, restitution and prohibition orders, depending on whether a case falls under the civil or criminal provisions of the Competition Act.

Next
Next

The Future of Marketing: Welcoming Students to SocialEast